Another Area Where the ‘Common Wisdom’ is wrong: Diet and Exercise

The most recent issue of Scientific American features an article that claims to be what science tells us about the current obesity epidemic, and what to do about it. Unfortunately, there is very little science in the article, and lots of wishful thinking, such as finding ways to keep everybody hungry all the time.

The author’s thesis is that simple overeating is what causes Americans and others to get fat. Their solution is the usual mantra: eat less meat and more grains and other carbohydrate-rich foods, and do lots of aerobic exercise. The problem is that this prescription isn’t based on history, and it isn’t based on science. There are no studies that show that that sort of diet and exercise regime actually leads to losing any significant amount of body fat.  (I do NOT consider losing 6 pounds of fat after a year of near-starvation and 20 or more hours of aerobic activity to be a significant weight loss. My bathroom scale can have me losing that amount after a large bowel movement or two!)

In fact, almost any farmer can tell you that if you want to make your cattle fat, then you should feed them lots of grains, instead of their normal diet of grass.

What’s more, the author manages to write an entire article about obesity without once mentioning the ‘elephant in the room’ that has changed many formerly fit pre-colonial people into people who are simultaneously malnourished and obese, all over the world.

The big change has been from high-fat, relatively meat-rich diets to more Western diets consisting of cheap, starchy vegetables and grains filled with carbohydrates that humans did NOT evolve to eat. Over and over again, native societies – like our own Native Americans here in the USA – that have made this dietary shift have developed diabetes, obesity, nutritional deficiencies, heart disease, strokes, dental cavities, and much more in their adult populations, while the children simultaneously suffer from serious dietary deficiencies, often being on the verge of starvation.

Looking at sub-Saharan Africa, it’s hard to think of people who work harder, all day long, than most African women, and they eat a diet high in grains, beans, and starchy vegetables and fruit (yams and plantains, for example). Yet many of them are fat or obese.

It seems to me (though I am not an expert at all) that it’s much more likely that the USDA nutritional pyramid, and the current, anti-scientific propaganda in favor of low-fat, high-carbohydrate foods, are causing, rather than curing, the current world-wide obesity epidemic. The author of the article apparently thinks that high-fat, low-carbohydrate diets are mere fads to be dismissed out of hand; he doesn’t even analyze any evidence in favor of, or against, their effectiveness at all.

How can a major article in 2011 that purports to be on ‘what science teaches us about obesity’ fail to even acknowledge Gary Taubes’ ground-breaking review and synthesis, now in two books and several articles, concerning the relevant literature on nutrition and obesity? Or are all the studies that were read and cited by Taubes also mere fads? You can look at some of his articles and books here, here, and here, and you can find his blog here.

The URI to TrackBack this entry is:

RSS feed for comments on this post.

4 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. “The Body You Want” is holding free group fitness workouts at 9:55 AM every Sunday during February, in conjunction with the Capital Area Food Bank.

    All you have to do is to show up at the Definitions Gym on Thomas Jefferson Street in Georgetown with a one-pound can of a high-protein food (tuna, sardines, salmon, peanut butter, etc).

    The video explaining what happens is here:

    These are *interval* classes, which means that you do activity A for about 15 to 20 seconds as hard and as fast as you can, and then you rest for 40-45 seconds. Repeat a couple of times, then go to activity B and do the same; then activity C; then activity D.

    It’s exhausting, but fun, and really gets your metabolism up. And the people are nice, too. (And you don’t have to bore yourself to tears for an hour on a treadmill or other machine.) Evidence of actual clinical trials shows that aerobic activity does not help you lose body fat, but interval-type anaerobic exercise most definitely does. Plus not eating grains, bread, and other carbohydrate-rich foods.

    The connection to Brookland? Josef Brandenburg, the founder of “The Body You Want”, grew up in Brookland here on Randolph Street, where his proud parents still live. His blog is here:


  2. The thing about food and diets today is, that when it comes to dieting they are relatively boring, I have found that the best way of keeping the weight off is to eat sensibly little and often rather than 3 structured meals, keep away from the biscuit tin and sweet stuff and you will stay a healthy weight and happy.


    • The frequency with which one eats meals doesn’t seem to matter much – at least not to me or folks I know.
      However, it is certainly a lot more enjoyable if you eat with others!
      As you say, staying away from the carbohydrates in the form of sweets and breads and most grains is key. And that includes beer and ice cream, my two favorites.
      I’ve lost about 30 or 40 pounds of fat in 2 years, and have no problem whatsoever in keeping them off. I’m never hungry.


  3. It is important that all of us as parents encourage our kids to eat healthy and understand that if we train our bodies to eat well and good, then we will even as adults. Alot of parents nowadays choose the easy option of fast food with some feeding their kids every meal with fast food, parents like this should be held accountable if their kids are fat.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: