Scores for DCPS 3rd Graders Show that “Rhee-form” DOESN’T WORK EVEN ON ITS OWN TERMS!

If you base your entire reputation on the promise of increasing standardized test scores, then you should suffer the consequences if your policies don’t work as advertised.

That is what is going on in DC.

The following graph and table, which shows that under the educational “Rheeform” regime of today, DCPS third-graders are scoring worse and worse.

(I can only go back four years because OSSE does not provide any records that I can get at that break down the scores by grade level. You can have a jolly good time searching through the data for yourself, if you like. Here is the link to the OSSE-DCPS-NCLB website.)

Notice in the table that the most recent dates are at the top. Thus, in reading, about 41% of all 3rd graders in DCPS are ‘passing’ the reading portion of the DC-CAS. However, two years ago, that rate was 49%, and the year before that it was 48%. Thus, the fraction of the 3rd grade classes this year ‘successful’ at reading, as shown by the One And Only, All-Exalted, DC-CAS, whose word and numbers have such power over adults (but don’t really matter all that much to the students, frankly), has dropped by 7 or 8 percentage points, which is in my opinion, considerable amount. And it went down a bit from last year, even as Rhee, Henderson, Kamras have been firing and demoralizing hundreds of teachers by making them teach to this stupid test.

And in math (which I used to teach, though not in the 3rd grade), the decline has been even worse: by 12 percentage points, from 49% ‘passing’ to 37% ‘passing’ today.

And may I add, the current type of Deformed Education, which desires to turn it into a militarized, regimented, test prep factory for working-class and minority kids, appears to bore the HECK out of the kids, in the process. It teaches them very little that is really useful, and seems to stifle their sense of joy, wonder, and exploration. Kids don’t really get up in the morning all buzzed that they are going  to take a tests. The only people who have a real stake in these tests are the adults. It is possible to keep order while giving students stupid worksheets based on flawed data in the DC-BAS, DIBELS, and so on, but is that teaching?

I have lots more graphs to come, but it’s too late at night already, and each graph takes me a lot of work.

I’m going in order by grade level, and will see if you can figure out, eventually, what went on in the 10th grade. I’ll deal with the charter schools in similar detail as well, and with the various ethnic/racial/national categories, too.

Published in: on August 3, 2011 at 9:51 pm  Comments (4)  

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://gfbrandenburg.wordpress.com/2011/08/03/scores-for-dcps-3rd-graders-show-that-rhee-form-doesnt-work-even-on-its-own-terms/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

4 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. How are you able to find the scores by grade level? I can only find the scores by school.

    By the way, I LOVE your blog.

    Like

    • It’s a bit tedious. You ask for the scores for all schools (all DCPS or even for a single school, or whatever) and then when you see the spreadsheet of the entire group, there is an option near the top of he spreadsheet which allows you to the scores by grades.
      BTW: for 2011, to get the scores for the charter schools, you have to subtract the scores and numbers of students of ALL publicly funded schools, minus the scores and numbers for regular DCPS only. What’s left are the scores for the charter schools.

      Like

    • It’s a bit tedious. You ask for the scores for all schools (all DCPS or even for a single school, or whatever) and then when you see the spreadsheet of the entire group, there is an option near the top of he spreadsheet which allows you to the scores by grades.
      BTW: for 2011, to get the scores for the charter schools, you have to subtract the scores and numbers of students of ALL publicly funded schools, minus the scores and numbers for regular DCPS only. What’s left are the scores for the charter schools.

      Like

  2. Thank you Guy, for all your hard work of this. And to think that at the public meeting back in July, Henderson was “celebrating” the results.

    I’m anxious too to see what’s happening in the 10th grade. My eyeballing of the scores in the comprehensive 9-12 high schools shows declines across the board. The only exception is Cardozo, whose reading and math scores moved up seven and two percentage points respectively, but are still in the 20’s. Yes – the 20’s.

    Like


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: